Character woes

Alright, Eawan is dead. I now have the opportunity to play another character, but which one damnit. I have two characters all made, all prepped and ready, with character soundtracks in process for both. They both have extensive back histories, deal with complicated issues and have all sorts of possibility to them. And I can't decide. I really need to talk to the ST's about this, see what they think of my proposition. Because it's too hard to decide.